All episodes
Episodes, not shows
Episodes like Shelterwood
You don't need another show to subscribe to — you need the episodes that scratch the same itch. These are the closest matches from other podcasts, based on what Shelterwood actually talks about.
24 matched episodes
Not scored yet
Bad Dream Labyrinth
Mayfair Watchers Society
25m ·
Not scored yet
A Very Important Meeting & Beneath the Streets of Edgewood Forest
Creepy
43m ·
Not scored yet
Lot 019 : Return To Sender // 12 Minutes
The Antiquarium of Sinister Happenings
26m ·
Not scored yet
Feed Drop: Something's Amiss at Juniper's House
The Harbingers
34m ·
Not scored yet
We Recommend: Thirteen
REDACTED
35m ·
Not scored yet
Jergen Kurtwood's Haunted Mill Tour
Mayfair Watchers Society
30m ·
Not scored yet
Shed & The Madness
Creepy
42m ·
Not scored yet
Presenting - The Gentleman From Hell
The Strata
29m ·
Not scored yet
A Girl I Found in the Woods is Being Hunted | Part 2
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
23m ·
Not scored yet
Meet our Friends: Malevolent
The White Vault
49m ·
Not scored yet
Episode 73: The Blood of Wolves
Old Gods of Appalachia
36m ·
Not scored yet
I Found Murder Tapes at a Thrift Store
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
27m ·
Not scored yet
Presenting - The Gentleman From Hell
The Road of Shadows
28m ·
Not scored yet
Lot 052 : If You Pass By Oak Hill Apartments and Hear My Calls For Help, Do Not Answer!
The Antiquarium of Sinister Happenings
30m ·
Not scored yet
We Recommend: The Gospel of Haven
REDACTED
24m ·
Not scored yet
Episode 89: Lost in the Shadows
Old Gods of Appalachia
45m ·
Not scored yet
Episode 1.10 - Nowhere Left To Go
The Road of Shadows
32m ·
Not scored yet
Feed Drop: Redacted
The Harbingers
20m ·
Not scored yet
INTRODUCING: Dark Woods
Morbid
3m ·
Not scored yet
CAMPFIRE: What Happened In The Woods
Full Body Chills
36m ·
Not scored yet
CAMPFIRE: The Last House on Adeline Lane
Full Body Chills
36m ·
Not scored yet
S4 Ep305: 305: Consuming Consequences - Chilling Tales for Dark Nights
Chilling Tales for Dark Nights — A Horror Fiction Anthology and Scary Stories Series Podcast
1h 22m ·
Not scored yet
434: 434: A Taste of Terror - Chilling Tales for Dark Nights
Chilling Tales for Dark Nights — A Horror Fiction Anthology and Scary Stories Series Podcast
54m ·
Not scored yet
S11 Ep12: S11E12 - "Unusual Practices" - Horror Hill
Horror Hill — A Horror Fiction Anthology and Scary Stories Series Podcast
1h 04m ·
Want a find like these in your inbox every morning? Free, one a day.
One email a day, unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.
Matched on episode content — what's actually said, summarized and compared — not on genre labels or chart position. That's how a tiny show's best hour can sit next to Shelterwood's.