All episodes
Episodes, not shows
Episodes like Midnight Monologue
You don't need another show to subscribe to — you need the episodes that scratch the same itch. These are the closest matches from other podcasts, based on what Midnight Monologue actually talks about.
24 matched episodes

Not scored yet
Entities We Can't Explain (Two Short Stories)
Scary Story Podcast
14m ·

Not scored yet
Silhouettes & Your House Is Haunted
Scary Story Podcast
22m ·

Another hour of scary spooky stories
Matt From Nomad’s
42m ·

Goblins of Eastern Kentucky
Snap Judgment
50m ·

Hour of Horror Stories
Matt From Nomad’s
46m ·

Ghost Ships
Everything Everywhere Daily: History, Science, Geography & More
14m ·

Not scored yet
Bealings Bells
Stuff You Missed in History Class
34m ·

The Waiting Game
Snap Judgment
48m ·

Not scored yet
Midnight Madness in Kentucky: The Kelly-Hopkinsville Encounter
Fringe Beyond Limits
1h 04m ·

Not scored yet
A Trucker Heard Knocking on His Semi. Then the Whole Truck Moved.
Bigfoot Society
1h 39m ·

Not scored yet
A 12-Year-Old Heard Something Scream Near Forks—Then Everyone Started Leaving
Bigfoot Society
1h 14m ·
Not scored yet
Wicked Whispers of the Bell Witch
Fringe Beyond Limits
55m ·

Not scored yet
Six Impossible Episodes: Ghost Stories
Stuff You Missed in History Class
38m ·

Not scored yet
Episode 23 Haunted Objects Part 2
Lights On Still Scared
49m ·

Not scored yet
The Glove Guy (With Jordan Bonaparte from The Night Time Podcast)
Morbid
1h 02m ·

Not scored yet
Episode 22 Haunted Objects Part 1
Lights On Still Scared
34m ·

Not scored yet
3 Underground Bunker Horror Stories
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
54m ·

Not scored yet
The Lady in the Bay Window: 21 Years of Unexplained Activity | William C. Grave
Pursuit of the Paranormal
58m ·

UFO sightings, meditation and portals - Don't Be Told
Pursuit of the Paranormal
1h 07m ·

Episode 92: Excursus I
Old Gods of Appalachia
39m ·

Ghosts of Sea and Shore | Haunting Season 2026
The Three Ravens Podcast
1h 37m ·

Not scored yet
Reddit's Scariest True Crime Ghost Stories
Crimes Of Reddit with Sabrina Deana-Roga & Alexis Linkletter
52m ·

Not scored yet
3 Night Shift Horror Stories
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
1h 08m ·

Not scored yet
Why Miners See Ghosts | Halloween Season
Cautionary Tales with Tim Harford
37m ·
Want a find like these in your inbox every morning? Free, one a day.
One email a day, unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.
Matched on episode content — what's actually said, summarized and compared — not on genre labels or chart position. That's how a tiny show's best hour can sit next to Midnight Monologue's.