All episodes
Episodes, not shows
Episodes like EXTRA ANORMAL
You don't need another show to subscribe to — you need the episodes that scratch the same itch. These are the closest matches from other podcasts, based on what EXTRA ANORMAL actually talks about.
24 matched episodes
47%MI EX SE CONVIRTIÓ EN NAHUAL — Camikaze
LOS MAFIA ⭐️
1h 11m ·
Not scored yet
La Isla de las Muñecas: The Island of the Dead-Eyed Dolls
Fringe Beyond Limits
1h 03m ·
48%POR SER VIRGEN ME DROGARON PARA VENDERME — Ashly
LOS MAFIA ⭐️
1h 21m ·
Not scored yet
Terrifyingly True Tales: A Halloween Special
Fringe Beyond Limits
1h 03m ·
Not scored yet
EP: 188 My Fiancé is Possessed *members only trailer
Blurry Creatures
8m ·
Not scored yet
Introducing: Hometown Ghost Stories
Creepy
1h 19m ·
Not scored yet
True Encounters with the Jinn
Midnight Monologue
1h 15m ·
Not scored yet
EP:64 Sasquatch and the graveyard
Sasquatch Chronicles
53m ·
Not scored yet
10 Disturbing Horror Stories (Best of 2025 Compilation)
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
7h 50m ·
Not scored yet
Horror in Mexico
MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
30m ·
Not scored yet
Strange Solutions (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
24m ·
Not scored yet
Brad's Bonkers Listener Tale
Morbid
48m ·
Not scored yet
EP: 366 Generational Curses and Cannibal Rituals: Breaking Free from Santeria and Occult Bloodlines *members only trailer
Blurry Creatures
18m ·
Not scored yet
Sleep Paralysis Demons
We're All Insane
56m ·
Not scored yet
Night Knockers: The Black‑Eyed Kids
Midnight Monologue
30m ·
Not scored yet
Listener Tales 98: Witches!
Morbid
52m ·
Not scored yet
My Tinder Date was Possessed
We're All Insane
22m ·
Not scored yet
Upcoming Show: Strange Property
Sasquatch Chronicles
7m ·
Not scored yet
RedHaunted #6 Don't Name Your Ghosts
RedHanded
43m ·
60%Episodio 50: Cosas que DESTRUYEN una relación: LA EX QUE VUELVE A APARECER
Podcast no Podcast
36m ·
Not scored yet
There's A Hidden Room In My House, It Leads To Another Dimension | Part 1
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
50m ·
Not scored yet
Day 8 - Dark Woods Demons & more
Creepy
58m ·
Not scored yet
Introducing a chilling new podcast: TWISTED TALES WITH HEIDI WONG
After Dark: Myths, Misdeeds & the Paranormal
7m ·
Not scored yet
Alien Apocalypse: Descent Into Darkness | Sci-Fi Creepypasta Cosmic Horror Story
Galactic Horrors
39m ·
Want a find like these in your inbox every morning? Free, one a day.
One email a day, unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.
Matched on episode content — what's actually said, summarized and compared — not on genre labels or chart position. That's how a tiny show's best hour can sit next to EXTRA ANORMAL's.