All episodes
Episodes, not shows
Episodes like EXTRA ANORMAL
You don't need another show to subscribe to — you need the episodes that scratch the same itch. These are the closest matches from other podcasts, based on what EXTRA ANORMAL actually talks about.
24 matched episodes

MI EX SE CONVIRTIÓ EN NAHUAL — Camikaze
LOS MAFIA ⭐️
1h 11m ·

POR SER VIRGEN ME DROGARON PARA VENDERME — Ashly
LOS MAFIA ⭐️
1h 21m ·
Not scored yet
La Isla de las Muñecas: The Island of the Dead-Eyed Dolls
Fringe Beyond Limits
1h 03m ·

Not scored yet
Halloween Special Part 1 : True Paranormal Stories
Pursuit of the Paranormal
59m ·

Not scored yet
An Interview with an Exorcist - Stephanie Brady
Pursuit of the Paranormal
59m ·

Not scored yet
There's A Hidden Room In My House, It Leads To Another Dimension | Part 1
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
51m ·

Not scored yet
Introducing: Hometown Ghost Stories
Creepy
1h 19m ·

Not scored yet
Terrifyingly True Tales: A Halloween Special
Fringe Beyond Limits
1h 03m ·

Not scored yet
3 Skinwalker Horror Stories
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
1h 00m ·

Not scored yet
Reddit's Scariest True Crime Ghost Stories
Crimes Of Reddit with Sabrina Deana-Roga & Alexis Linkletter
52m ·

Not scored yet
EP: 188 My Fiancé is Possessed *members only trailer
Blurry Creatures
8m ·

Not scored yet
True Encounters with the Jinn
Midnight Monologue
1h 15m ·

Not scored yet
Fr. Cruz Shares Exorcism Stories
The Exorcist Files
45m ·

Not scored yet
Tales from the Mexican Desert
Scary Story Podcast
24m ·

Not scored yet
A Call For Silvia (And Four More Creepy Short Stories)
Scary Story Podcast
20m ·

Not scored yet
Brad's Bonkers Listener Tale
Morbid
48m ·

Not scored yet
Horror in Mexico
MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
30m ·

Not scored yet
Strange Solutions (PODCAST EXCLUSIVE EPISODE)
MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
24m ·

Another hour of scary spooky stories
Matt From Nomad’s
42m ·

Not scored yet
My Neighbor Has Been SECRETLY Living In My Apartment For MONTHS!
Mark Narrations - Reddit Stories
24m ·

Not scored yet
Sleep Paralysis Demons
We're All Insane
56m ·

Not scored yet
EP:64 Sasquatch and the graveyard
Sasquatch Chronicles
53m ·

Not scored yet
Some weird conspiracy theories
Matt From Nomad’s
13m ·

Not scored yet
EP: 333 Ex-Satanic High Priest with John Ramirez *members only trailer
Blurry Creatures
8m ·
Want a find like these in your inbox every morning? Free, one a day.
One email a day, unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.
Matched on episode content — what's actually said, summarized and compared — not on genre labels or chart position. That's how a tiny show's best hour can sit next to EXTRA ANORMAL's.