All episodes
Episodes, not shows
Episodes like Creepy
You don't need another show to subscribe to — you need the episodes that scratch the same itch. These are the closest matches from other podcasts, based on what Creepy actually talks about.
10 matched episodes
Not scored yet
S19: NoSleep Podcast - Tales of the Moon Crawler Part 1
The NoSleep Podcast
1h 10m ·
Not scored yet
S19: NoSleep Podcast - Tales of the Moon Crawler Part 2
The NoSleep Podcast
1h 08m ·
Not scored yet
A Song Of Death And The Deep
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
44m ·
Not scored yet
I Accidentally Gave My Sister a Haunted Candle
Scary Horror Stories by Dr. NoSleep
45m ·
Not scored yet
Camping Horror Stories Vol. IV
MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
33m ·
Not scored yet
Camping Horror Stories
MrBallen Podcast: Strange, Dark & Mysterious Stories
30m ·
Not scored yet
Relaxed Fit: Creepypasta XVII - My Teeth Itch
Last Podcast On The Left
1h 28m ·
Not scored yet
The World Is A SIMULATION… And It's Shutting Down | Sci-Fi Creepypasta
Galactic Horrors
32m ·
Not scored yet
The Glutton of the Dark: Death by a Thousand Consumptions | Sci-Fi Creepypasta
Galactic Horrors
37m ·
Not scored yet
Episode 224: Creepypasta XI - Lemon Clams
Last Podcast On The Left
52m ·
Want a find like these in your inbox every morning? Free, one a day.
One email a day, unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.
Matched on episode content — what's actually said, summarized and compared — not on genre labels or chart position. That's how a tiny show's best hour can sit next to Creepy's.