

How long can an NFL team sustain an elite defense?
It's May, dear TAFS listener, and you know what that means: The real NFL offseason is here. We kick it off by opening up the mailbag, and you all delivered once again. Robert Mays and Dave Helman answer questions on the durability of elite defenses, hypothetical teams built entirely of one draft class, possible trades…
We score an episode from what we can actually measure — its reach and engagement, what listeners say about it, and what it covers. We don't have those signals for this one yet, so it doesn't get a number.
Buzzmeter says it's buzzing across platforms — the Hive Vote says whether the people who actually listened liked it.
Rate this episode
Add your vote to the Hive — listeners rate every episode after they finish.
- No reviews yet — be the first.
More from The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL
See all episodes →
Commanders come back to stun Giants, 24-21

Week 9 recap: Bears survive, Jordan Love thumps Patriots & WTF NFC South

2026 Midseason Awards: Joe Burrow, Josh Allen, or Jordan Love?
Similar episodes from other shows
More like The Athletic Football Show: A show about the NFL →
Bear Down or Up? Evaluating Offseason Moves and Needs

Draft Mailbag! Love Vs. Tate, Carson Beck Hate, How Many DKs Can Block Myles Garrett, the Best Feeling in Sports, and Craig's Vegas Check-in

Eagles passing attack, Expectations for Mayfield & Maye, Can Chiefs rookie transform OL?

Cowboys, Bears, & the Eagles Rollercoaster (feat. Dave Helman, Ten Day Tony & Jeremy Tache)
One great episode in your inbox, daily — free.
One email a day, unsubscribe anytime. No spam, ever.