Serialously with Annie Elise — 387: The Family Massacre Hidden Behind a Mansion Fire | The Paul Caneiro Case

SCOUT· 65%1h 08m·2026-04-20·True Crime

387: The Family Massacre Hidden Behind a Mansion Fire | The Paul Caneiro Case

Serialously with Annie Elise · 387

On the same morning in a quiet New Jersey suburb, two homes connected to the Caniero family go up in flames, just hours apart. At Paul Caniero’s house, everyone escapes safely. But at his brother Keith Caniero’s home, firefighters arrive to something far more chilling: a body on the front lawn and a devastating…

Listen now

Buzzmeter · cross-platform

65%

SCOUT

Scout bees are checking it out — divided opinions, the swarm hasn't committed.

Hive Vote · Skep listeners

New on SkepAwaiting the hive's first votes

Buzzmeter says it's buzzing across platforms — the Hive Vote says whether the people who actually listened liked it.

Rate this episode

Add your vote to the Hive — listeners rate every episode after they finish.

Recent reviews

No reviews yet — be the first.

387: The Family Massacre Hidden Behind a Mansion Fire | The Paul Caneiro Case

Rate this episode

More from Serialously with Annie Elise

416: Incest Dad Basically Walks Free, Teen Marly Kinney Vanishes At Boat Party & Sisters Murder and Smile After

403: Mackenzie’s Cringey Jail Calls, TikToker & Her Dad Plan Murder, & Katie Price Missing Husband

402: Group of 5 Friends Charged in Death of 16-Year-Old Teen Girl | Justice for Kayla Huff